Pension schemes are a vital part of a country's economy, reflecting gratitude to seniors for their years of service. These plans ensure financial security in retirement, acknowledge the contributions made by individuals throughout their working lives, and play a crucial role in sustaining economic stability.
With various pension schemes available choosing one can be overwhelming. Worry not, we have for you a comprehensive guide to pension schemes. A detailed analysis of UPS vs NPS vs OPS will help you decide which one would be most suitable for you.
Introduction to Pension Schemes: UPS, NPS, and OPS
The Indian government has also been quite sensitive to the pensioners. It is estimated that in the financial year 2024, central and state governments together spent about ₹9.6 trillion on employee pensions. Recently the NDA government introduced the Unified Pension Scheme. Along with the other prevalent schemes, the introduction of this new scheme has evoked different reactions from different sectors.
The three prominent pension schemes in the country today are:
- Unified Pension Scheme
The Unified Pension Scheme is a very recent addition by the Prime Minister Narendra Modi-led government. This new pension scheme will come into being from FY2025-26.
- National Pension System
National Pension System, better known as the NPS, was introduced in the year 2004. The scheme was earlier only for government employees but was then extended to all sectors in 2009.
- Old Pension Scheme
As the name suggests, the Old Pension Scheme is the oldest scheme out of the three. Under this scheme, government employees having put in a minimum of 10 years of service, receive a pension.
Read on as we discuss UPS vs NPS vs OPS in detail.
What is UPS (Unified Pension Scheme) pension?
Let us begin with the Unified Pension Scheme.
Overview and Key Features
In the history of pension schemes, UPS is the latest addition. UPS is a pension scheme, however, here an employee has to contribute 10% of their basic pay and the DA (dearness allowance). The government’s share will be 18.5%, which stands at 14% for NPS.
Eligibility Criteria
As per the information received, employees who have put in 25 years of service will receive a pension that equals 50% (half) of the average salary in the last 1 year/ 12 months.
Benefits and Drawbacks
The benefits of the UPS are listed below:
The policy is said to offer 5 key benefits:
- Assured Pension
- Assured Family Pension
- Assured Minimum Pension
- Inflation Indexation
- Gratuity
The scheme has been designed to provide adequate financial security to the employees and their families.
However, keep in mind that the taxation details are still awaited. Also, many consider the Unified Pension System to be worse than the National Pension System. People consider that even after contributing 10% of the basic pay for the whole service period, pensioners will not receive a lump sum. Many consider that the new pension scheme does not offer the required financial stability.
What is an NPS (National Pension System) pension?
Now, let us get into the National Pension Scheme details.
Overview and Key Features
The launch of the NPS in 2004, transformed the existing pension system, which is currently known as the Old Pension Scheme. Under the PFRDA, Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority, NPS is a voluntary investment program that offers pension post-retirement. Here, government employees contribute 10% of their basic salary plus DA, while the government contributes 14%.
Eligibility Criteria
The National Pension Scheme was extended to all sectors in the year 2009 except armed forces.
Benefits and Drawbacks
The benefits of NPS are as follows:
What is an OPS (Old Pension Scheme) pension?
We will now discuss the Old Pension Scheme.
Overview and Key Features
This government-approved pension scheme for government employees offers a guaranteed monthly pension to those who have put in a minimum of 10 years of service. Assured pensions amount equal to 50% of the average basic pay over the previous 12 months before retirement for employees with at least 25 years of service.
Eligibility Criteria
OPS is for:Central government employees appointed before the NPS notification date which is 22 December 2003.
Benefits and Drawbacks
The benefits of OPS are as follows:
- The is no deduction from the employee's income while they are in service.
- There is a pension revision twice a year.
- Employees and their spouses get the pension benefit.
But at the same time, know that:
- Pensioners do not receive any corpus at the time of retirement.
- OPS puts a big burden on the central and state governments.
- Pension liabilities keep growing year after year.
UPS vs NPS vs OPS: Key Differences
Let us break down the key differences between UPS, NPS, and OPS.
Feature
| Unified Pension Scheme (UPS)
| National Pension System (NPS)
| Old Pension Scheme (OPS)
|
Pension Type
| Combination of OPS and NPS elements, potentially offering a balance of guaranteed returns and market-linked benefits.
| Market-linked, with no guaranteed returns; depends on market performance and contributions.
| Guaranteed pension based on the last drawn salary; inflation linked.
|
Contribution and Investment
| Yet to be defined but expected to require employee contributions, similar to NPS. Employee contribution (10%) + government contribution (18.5%) of basic salary + DA.
| Employee contribution (10%) + government contribution (14%) of basic salary + DA.
| No employee contribution; entirely government funded.
|
Payouts
| Likely offers a moderate corpus, combining the security of OPS with NPS's growth potential.
| Potential for a larger corpus due to market-linked investments.
| Fixed pension; no corpus accumulation
|
Returns
| Moderate risk with a mix of guaranteed and market-linked returns.
| Moderate risk due to market dependence, but also higher growth potential.
| Low-risk, fully guaranteed pension.
|
Political Opinion on UPS & NPS
The Modi government's new Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) has caused a lot of political arguments. The government says the scheme meets a long-time request from government workers. However, since the Union cabinet approved it on August 24, there has been a heated debate between the ruling Bhartiya Janata Party (BJP) and the Opposition, led by the Congress party.
Some government employees were unhappy with the UPS during the Lok Sabha elections. Critics, like AAP spokesperson Neel Garg, argue that the UPS is worse than the National Pension System (NPS). They point out that employees must contribute 10% of their basic pay throughout their careers but won’t get a lump sum back. Instead, their pension will be based on the last drawn basic salary, which is 50% of the average basic pay of their final year.
Conclusion: Making an Informed Decision
In conclusion, selecting the right pension scheme hinges on your financial priorities and risk appetite. While the OPS guarantees an inflation-linked pension, the NPS provides the opportunity to build a potentially larger retirement corpus. A new concept still to be launched, the UPS is expected to offer a balanced approach with both security and growth potential, ideal for those seeking a middle ground.
NPS is best suited for those willing to take on market risks for the chance of a larger retirement corpus. OPS, with its guaranteed, inflation-linked pension, might be perfect for those who prioritise stability and predictability. Carefully assess your needs to choose the scheme that best fits your retirement goals so that you can make an informed decision.
Disclaimer: Investments in the securities market are subject to market risk, read all related documents carefully before investing.
This content is for educational purposes only. Securities quoted are exemplary and not recommendatory.
For All Disclaimers Click Here: https://bit.ly/3Tcsfuc