What is the Modigliani-Miller (M&M) Theorem?
The Modigliani-Miller Theorem is a famous concept in finance, which says that a company’s value remains the same regardless of its capital structure. A company can raise finance through two sources mainly: equity and debt.
Equity means the funds provided by a company’s shareholders, who are its owners. However, debt means the funds provided as loans by external parties, like banks and other financiers. A firm’s capital structure shows the proportion of equity and debt in its financing.
The M&M Theorem suggests that a company’s value remains the same no matter what percentage of its overall funds have been contributed by equity or debt.
Understanding the History of the Modigliani-Miller Theorem in Detail
Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller were two economists who developed this theory in 1958. As discussed, their main idea was that a firm’s capital structure does not affect its value.
However, the first version of this theory had several limitations. For example, it assumes perfectly efficient markets, wherein companies do not pay taxes. But, in real life, companies pay taxes. Initially, the theory also assumed that there are no bankruptcy costs and there is no asymmetric information. But, these two assumptions too were unrealistic because there are costs associated with bankruptcy and information is rarely symmetric in the market.
Hence, to deal with the limitations of the first version, Miller and Modigliani came out with the second version of their theorem in which they included bankruptcy costs, taxes, and asymmetric information.
What the Modigliani-Miller Theorem Argues
The Modigliani-Miller theorem argues that a company’s value depends upon its business operations and not upon how it finances its capital. Let us take the case of a software manufacturer.
As per this theorem, the value of this company depends upon how well it manufactures and sells its software. Further, the value of the software manufacturer’s business has nothing to do with its capital structure. This business can raise capital from debt and equity in a 50:50 ratio, 70:30 ratio, or any other ratio. Changing the proportion of debt and capital will not change the business’s value.
This theorem rests on the assumption that there are no taxes, no bankruptcy costs, and no transaction costs. Besides, it also assumes that all investors have equal access to information.
When a company raises money through debt, it has to pay interest on it. Since interest expense is tax deductible, it reduces a firm’s tax burden. However, the Modigliani-Miller theorem assumes no taxes.
Similarly, debt financing also puts an obligation on a company to pay back the loans. If it is unable to do so, it has to file for bankruptcy. Moreover, bankruptcy-related costs can badly affect its value. However, since this theorem assumes no such costs, they do not affect a firm’s value.
What is the Reverse M&M Theorem in Finance?
As per the Reverse Modigliani-Miller theorem, a firm’s capital structure affects its value through different levers. The levers a company can use to change its value are based on the assumptions made by the Modigliani-Miller theorem.
Hence, the reverse theorem suggests that a firm’s value can be changed by providing or withholding information to various kinds of investors. It also proposes that increasing or decreasing taxes can change a company’s value.
The reverse theorem also suggests that bankruptcy-related costs can impact a firm’s value. In essence, the reverse M&M theorem takes the original M&M theorem and turns it on its head by challenging its assumptions.
Were Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller Recognized Economists?
Both Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller were acknowledged for their immense contributions to the field of finance and economics. Modigliani was awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1985 for his analyses of saving and financial markets.
Then, in 1990, Miller was awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics for his work related to the theory of financial economics.
What is a Company's Capital Structure?
A company’s capital structure reflects how it finances its operations and growth. There are predominantly two sources of finance for a company, which are explained below:
Equity: Equity refers to the finance raised by a company from its shareholders. It could be of two types. Common equity represents those shareholders who have ownership in a firm and have voting rights on important matters. However, a firm is not under an obligation to pay dividends to them. On the other hand, shareholders who provide preferred equity receive fixed dividends from a firm but they do not have voting rights in most cases.
Debt: Debt refers to the money borrowed by a company from banks or other financial institutions. A company has to mandatorily pay interest on the debt it raises. Besides, it also has to pay back the loans it has raised based on the terms agreed upon.
Limitations of the Modigliani-Miller Theorem
While the M&M theorem is important, it has a few limitations, which are explained below:
No taxes: This theorem assumes that taxes do not exist, which is not the case. Companies pay taxes in all countries. However, the tax rate may vary from one country to another.
Zero bankruptcy costs: The M&M theorem argues that there are no bankruptcy costs. However, in the real world, when a firm faces bankruptcy, it has to pay legal fees. Besides, bankruptcy badly affects a firm’s reputation, which is also a kind of cost.
No asymmetric information: This theorem rests on the assumption that all stakeholders have equal access to information, which is not the case in the real world. For example, majority shareholders of a company often have more information about its workings than minority shareholders.
Conclusion
Whether you are about to open a demat account or are a seasoned investor, you should understand the M&M theorem. You can gain interesting insights by analysing whether its assumptions hold in the stock market or not. Suppose you find that the companies that raise debt can generate higher value than companies that use only equity to raise finance. Hence, you can buy shares of companies that use debt financing. So, the M&M theorem can help you analyse companies and decide whether to invest in them or not.
Do you have a trading account app or demat account app?
You can open an account with Bajaj Broking in minutes.
Download the Bajaj Broking app now from Play Store or App Store.
Disclaimer: Investments in the securities market are subject to market risk, read all related documents carefully before investing.
This content is for educational purposes only. Securities quoted are exemplary and not recommendatory.
For All Disclaimers Click Here: https://bit.ly/3Tcsfuc